Quote:
Originally Posted by Itse
Hmm... Has the management actually said something to the tune of "the 12 best players will play"?
I'm asking because I don't remember hearing that, and more importantly it would be contrary to the previous message of "prospects will go where they will develop best".
So guy like Granlund who seems to be about as ready as they come for example just has to be better than a vet to make the team, giving him a good chance.
A guy like Gaudreau has to show not only that he's good, but also that sending him to Adirondack would not make a difference to his development.
|
Treliving was throwing around the classic "Meritocracy" quotes a couple of months ago. I'll try & find the quotes to back that up...
It's a bit of a dilemma; just because these players are good enough to outplay a veteran (on a bottom 5 team) for a roster spot doesn't necessarily mean they wouldn't be better served by a bit of seasoning in the minors (Gaudreau) or junior (Bennett). There's a risk that rushing these players will lower their chances of reaching their potential 'ceiling', but if they can step right in and contribute then who is to say they can't learn what they need to learn on the fly in the NHL?
It's a bloody difficult decision. We sure as hell don't want to Oilers these players. Sure, they would make the team better in the short term, but if they develop properly they should make the team a future contender.
I feel Granlund is ready, though, and he is leading the race to be Backlund's injury replacement. Should get a good long look.