Originally Posted by Titan

The way I read that pamphlet, if you are driving you must provide ID, full stop.

That is likely not a Charter issue but a Traffic Safety Act issue, which makes sense.

If you are detained you have the right to a lawyer, but that pamphlet is unclear as to whether they can then take your ID. Same as being arrested, can they take your ID without your consent? Sounds like it, if it is in conjunction with a detention or arrest.