View Single Post
Old 08-17-2014, 07:46 PM   #541
Chill Cosby
Lifetime Suspension
 
Join Date: Jun 2014
Exp:
Default Design a Calgarypuck Logo!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Split98 View Post
Constructive criticism is fantastic, and everyone here had responded amazingly well to it. 'That sucks' and discouraging people from posting isn't what we should be promoting. Let's keep this a fun thread, if your here to bash someone's ideas and efforts please keep your opinions to yourself. We don't want people giving up efforts because they don't feel appreciated or fear getting bashed.

I would say it's pretty constructive to suggest someone try out a new idea because their latest versions of a old idea aren't living up to their first few iterations. I didn't see him ever say "That sucks" or bash your ideas, but granted, they aren't my ideas, so maybe I'm taking it differently.

Regardless, I would agree with the criticism of the Grat version. The first thing it looked like to me was a guy in a suit doing a salute.

Is there an opportunity to use a less distinct player outline in general? I think it's been said before, but having Monahan on it or any current Flames player is definitely going to date it. Just my opinion of course. Hope it isn't taken personally
Chill Cosby is offline   Reply With Quote