Quote:
Originally Posted by Otto-matic
IMO it's a case of the younger crowd vs the older crowd,
I voted Gelinas for the obvious 04 magic he produced but also because he was around when I was alive.
|
I agree it's more about age here, as well maybe which is fresher in a person's mind. I am old enough to have watched Reinhart in his prime and I tell you there was something special about his play, yes I liked the 2004 playoffs but who's to say that someone else wouldn't have scored those goals without him being there? Reinhart played fantastic for 9 seasons and wins my vote.