Ahhh good ol' Clarke Wilm. Forgot about that guy.
Want to pick Paul Reinhart for his 2 way play, plus his ability to play forward. Also always showed up during the playoffs. If he hadn't been traded to the Cansucks the year before we won the Cup I think he would have had my vote.
That said, I have to go with Mr. Gelinas. The magic of him ending every series in 04 cannot be overstated. Pure clutch. He should have also been credited with the Stanley Cup winning goal because that damn puck was across the line.