Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post

YogiBerra · 08-14-2014, 03:21 AM

HF Poster: Johnny Gaudreau just had the most dominant collegiate season since Paul Kariya 20 years ago and doesn't crack the top 10?

I'm not a Flames fan, or BC fan, or anything, but I've seen this kid play, and he flat out dominates the competition. Has dominated nearly every game he's played in for the last 2+ years. He deserves to be higher than a lot of those players.

Also as an aside, I have very high opinion of Fiala. Real deal.
Pronman: I see a 5-9/non bulky F with high-end to elite hands and IQ, pretty good but not amazing skating for his size, not a physical force, and not all that valuable defensively. That's a potential quality top 6 forward in my eyes, but he'd need to be a top 25 skater in the NHL to get into the kind of range you suggest, which is that of a potential all-star.

Pronmans' response so his opinion is if your small you have to be one of the best skaters in the NHL to make it. Seems like a pretty narrow view; I wouldn't consider Kane, ST. Louis or a lot of the other small guys who have made it top 25 skaters but they get by fine. Pronmans' lists are always so bad.

08-14-2014, 03:21 AM	#48
YogiBerra Crash and Bang Winger Join Date: Nov 2013 Location: Calgary Exp:	HF Poster: Johnny Gaudreau just had the most dominant collegiate season since Paul Kariya 20 years ago and doesn't crack the top 10? I'm not a Flames fan, or BC fan, or anything, but I've seen this kid play, and he flat out dominates the competition. Has dominated nearly every game he's played in for the last 2+ years. He deserves to be higher than a lot of those players. Also as an aside, I have very high opinion of Fiala. Real deal. Pronman: I see a 5-9/non bulky F with high-end to elite hands and IQ, pretty good but not amazing skating for his size, not a physical force, and not all that valuable defensively. That's a potential quality top 6 forward in my eyes, but he'd need to be a top 25 skater in the NHL to get into the kind of range you suggest, which is that of a potential all-star. Pronmans' response so his opinion is if your small you have to be one of the best skaters in the NHL to make it. Seems like a pretty narrow view; I wouldn't consider Kane, ST. Louis or a lot of the other small guys who have made it top 25 skaters but they get by fine. Pronmans' lists are always so bad.