Quote:
Originally Posted by Russic
IGN seems to be an easy target, but I find I almost always agree with the reviews. That being said, because I listen to the podcasts I know that there are pre-existing biases towards certain genres that you have to factor in. For example, Greg Miller's favourite games are 3rd person action games, so something like Uncharted 3 is right in his wheelhouse. I've even listened to IGN podcasts where they collectively rag on him for that review, but it was his review and his opinion. I prefer things to be that way. It's the same with Colin Moriarty and his enjoyment of indie games. I enjoy indie games but I don't love them - so when he gives something an 8.5, I know it's probably more of a 7.5 in my books.
|
I also like how they run most of the Playstation stuff but have no problems with call them out on terrible moves the company makes. Like them calling out how Sony has sent games "out to die" in the past with little market or support. Or why they have a new segment now mocking the lack of ability to change your PSN name.
Like I said, I don't frequent Gamespot much these days but I'll maybe check it out a bit more. But if Erick Estrada is right and their marketing guy can basically meddle or rules over their editorial department . . . that sounds terrible. No idea how everybody doesn't end up being a shill if the guys taking ad money have control over you and your work - and can fire you (or the Editorial Director!) for not towing the marketing line.