I'm going to assume that part of allowing a second chance is a clean break, which would be defeated by what is being suggested. Philosophically, I appreciate the idea of allowing a second chance, depending on circumstances. I love a good game of guess-who-the-returning-poster is as much as anyone, but more out of curiosity and humour than anything.
But when people start going off the rails and returning to their previous way of posting, or going back to previous habits that earned them a ban in the first place, I am all for them being called out, or any of the other consequences that arise from failing to learn from previous negative behaviours.
|