Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaskal
Not everyone can decisively just form a big ranking list of all our prospects.
Bennett, Gaudreau and even Sven were pretty obvious, but it becomes a crapshoot after that. I like the format Bingo is using because it helps with posters who are indecisive (me) about who fits where, past a certain threshold.
If what you're suggesting was implemented, like a points system with #1 getting the most, #30 getting a single point etc, I feel that'd be much more likely to result in a mixed up hodgepodge of middle dwellers with still no real distinguished ranking rather than the clean process of elimination we're using currently.
|
No I'm just suggesting that everyone gets one vote per player. You put that player where you think they slot according to whatever your opinion is and that was your vote for that player. If some players get multiple votes and others don't, it's an unfair process, statistically. Plus then I don't get to see how my own personal list turns out because I voted one guy the whole time.
I guess I look at like if each scout submitted a list of players and then Treliving ranked them according to amount of 1st place, second place, third place votes (no points to each level, just the total amount of votes), what type of list would he have? Would it not be a general prospect ranking? A guy wouldn't be able to vote for any player multiple times, each player only has 1 rank.