Having an open discussion about who is a possible returnee is a good idea. Maybe less "fun" then the last one was, but that thread as a great way to contain the discussion and do some sorting out that 2-3 moderators can't do.
The moderators using that thread to as a two-way street to communicate would be beneficial as well. If the group is onto somebody and the moderators are already aware then can give us the heads up, similar to how KevanGuy dropped the "ok ok, I get it" for undercoverbrother.
The board is a community and what you're suggesting, is just a little too naive. Yes, it's an online community but that doesn't mean someone should be a total loser, get banned, put on a disguise and join in again right away. Users being able to vent and discuss returnees is good for the board, letting off some steam.
Your last sentence is exactly what the board needs a little of. Your moderating style and decisions are making the board a little too vanilla, Ken.
|