[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by GGG

He was positive on Day 1

Ok, it is clear you think I am up to something.

His first vote was HG15:

Originally Posted by strombad

Alright, let me jump in with a bit of theory here.

Voting based on inactivity worked great last time. We (for the most part) were all rookies so I think a lot of people weren't quite sure how to play. We got extremely lucky.

The difference now is that this time at least some of the mafia have either: A. Played before or B. Watched the last game. This game is about learning, do you really think everyone involved in the mafia is going to pipe down and chill out based on the danger that put them in last time? No. It was pretty clear that being vocal is the best "defence".

Now, here is the other side of my theory. Personally, I think there is absolutely no way that mafia aren't being at least somewhat active based on the last game, it would be stupid to just sit back and watch the same thing happen all over again. That being said, I'm currently most suspicious of Hockeyguy15, and quite frankly, I think he's the best option to vote out (and here's why):

- Advocating for "inactive" voting (which makes no sense to suggest considering it ignores the mafia's ability to learn, might it be alright after day 2 or 3? Of course, but mafia are absolutely going to have a presence on day 1 after last game)
- Casting suspicion on multiple people (which after 1 real time day serves only to attack people during their feeling out process)
- High post count, low value count (no offence HG15, but you're just throwing a ton of stuff at the wall and seeing what sticks. On day 1 that's a silly thing to do, and it didn't exactly help last time)

If HG15 is a townsperson, then that's too bad, but his high post count last time wasn't crucial to victory and he's now adamantly going after inactive posters (which, if mafia would buy him multiple game days if people believed him, considering how high his post count actually is and the fact that he would NEVER be considered an inactive poster). Trying to lead the game THIS heavily after only 24 hours or so is a great idea if you're management.

Sorry bro.

Vote: Hockeyguy15

Here is the first vote summation by Mazrim

Originally Posted by Mazrim

Vote Count:

With 30 alive, it takes 16 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 10 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (21): kermitology, hmmhmmcamo, bizaro86, flameswin, CofR, starseed, devo22, agulati, transplant99, Crazy Bacon Legs, Baxter Renegade, HalifaxDrunk, undercoverbrother, dsavillian, Timbo, GP_Matt, activeStick, Delgar, Aeneas, Completely, DropIt

Voting:
ineedanother (3): Rathji, Street Pharmacist, CaptainCrunch
activeStick (2): GGG, ineedanother
Hockeyguy15 (1): strombad
Completely (1): Lego Man
strombad (1): Hockeyguy15
Crazy Bacon Legs (1): Oling_Roachinen

Deadline is Sunday, May 4th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.