[hmmhmmcamo]

Originally Posted by Rathji

Hmmhmmcamo, why is transplant99 voting for ineedanother a concern for you?

I mean, a bunch of us did it, based off my suspicion, which seemed logical at the time. But if there is something more to your question that I can't see, it might mean there is more reason than just being inactive.

Yesterday there was some discussion about the inactive posters. When I started looking closer at transplant I thought his lack of posting combined with quietly jumping in on the ineedanother vote in the middle of the night was suspicious.

Transplant frequently posts in the FOI forum but hasn't really been seen since the game started. After he was called out yesterday he popped in and mentioned work, but that hasn't stopped him from contributing to these forums in the past.

I know it's not a lot to go on, but when looking at the inactive posters it stuck out to me.

Originally Posted by bizaro86

The reason I was in favour of following ineedanother into hmmhmmcamo is that we know he is town, so even if he's not 100% right we don't need to worry about his motives. The fact that the voting for hmmhmmcamo has fizzled out and now people have moved on to Active Stick and Transplan99 makes me a bit suspicious. Not that I'm sure Active Stick and Transplant99 are town, but more that I'm suspicious of the motives of those who directed attention away from voting hmmhmmcamo.

At this point I think we're at risk of having a split vote and not lynching anyone, which I think hurts us as we lose out on information from both the voting patterns and the card flip.

I'm keeping my vote for now, and will try and go through the thread again to see if I can figure anything else out.

Originally Posted by flameswin

I'm on board with following Ineedanother, at least at the beginning here. He really has to start getting a concrete plan and reasoning down, though. So far, he doesn't really seem that comfortable being a leader, so all we really have from him so far is "At least we know he isn't purposely mis-directing us".

The closest he's come so far to leading is passively saying that Baxter-Renegade hasn't posted much. But that seemed more like an "Everyone wants me to say something, so here's something off the top of my head" type of response than anything."

The problem with following ineedanother right now (besides him voting for me ) is that he's already made a couple mistakes in judgement (role reveal early and Timbo) and has admitted that he's a new player and not really sure what to do. Voting me out will make it three mistakes.

If the consensus becomes "do what ineedanother does", it makes it a lot easier for the Mafia to stay hidden by just going with the crowd and using that in their defense later. I don't see how we pick up on any patterns going this way.

By going with transplant99 now, we are either getting rid of mafia player that is trying to lay low, or a town player that isn't participating and making it easier for the Mafia to fly under the radar with the other inactive players.