I've reviewed the thread, the way HD defended himself doesn't strike me as genuine townie, also, he was active at the time but didn't do anything to dissuade anyone from HG.
I believe HG is town.
So I'm likely to vote HD, take a look and consider it.
I'm also considering the lowest posters:
mmhmmcamo 4 Crazy Bacon Legs 4 CofR 3 Oling_Roachinen 3 Baxter Renegade 2 transplant99 1