Quote:
Originally Posted by strombad
Actually, MOST defencemen fall outside of the range of the original graph you posted.
Defencemen with worse QoC than Keith:
179 out of 262, or 68%
Again, not arguing Keith's QoC was brilliant, but "most" is a lie.
Considering the difference between Chara and Keith is 1.6% (1.2% between Weber and Keith) and the chart ranges 4.8% (a 33% spread), it's not quite as significant as the 8.6% gap between Keith and Weber (1.4% between Keith and Chara) on a chart that ranges 21.2% (41% spread).
|
Chara is significantly better defensively than Keith. Keith is much better offensively.
I doubt Chara will win, but when you consider he spent a large portion of his year without Seidenberg and was going up against other team's best players with Dougie Hamilton or Boychuk he had one hell of year.