Quote:
Originally Posted by trackercowe
I think those are actually pretty good numbers comparatively. And 1999 was a complete bust for everyone, only a handful of players actually did anything in the league.
So McPhee drafted 25 players to play more than 100 games, and that makes him a terrible GM? Well Holland only drafted 21 in the same period of time, so I guess by that assertion he must be even worse.
|
McPhee had 25 more picks than Holland during the same period, his percentage is lower in terms of producing players who got a cup of coffee.
McPhee had way more 1st and 2nd round picks than Holland (34 for McPhee compared with 14 for Holland). McPhee despite a plethora of top picks still was horrific in the draft.
McPhee only picked 7 players over all those years outside the first two rounds who got a cup of coffee in the NHL, Holland has 10. McPhee cannot find players after the first two rounds.
Holland's guys have played more combined games than McPhee's, Holland despite having far worst drafting position has drafted collectively in his 21 far superior players to McPhee.
Holland is superior in every way to McPhee in the draft. Based on any sort of drafting analysis McPhee is one of the worst in the NHL over the past 17 years.