Four defective shirts? How does that even happen? I would stop shopping there based on quality of merchandise, not on their return policy.
Also, just my opinion, but if I have a shirt that breaks down in two years I would probably just accept that. I don't know if it's fair to expect a shirt to have an endless lifespan.
Sucks they changed the policy on you retroactively, but I can understand it from their point of view.
__________________
|