Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post - CP Lockout Mafia - Game Over

octothorp · 03-26-2014, 12:04 PM

Went and reread the thread, focusing on guys who are still remaining and looking not only at how they vote, but who they voice suspicions about. Someone stating suspicions about a guy who turns out to be MGMT before the votes start to pile up is a stronger tell of being a player than how they vote.

I may have missed votes here and there (it's a long thread and I did this late at night), so if you see that I've made an error about you or someone else, please correct me!

Here are the guys I think have shown reasonably strong player tells:

Wood: vote #2 on drake, #10 on regulator, #5 on timbo
dsavillian: #6 for drake, #3 on regulator (and noted suspicions of regulator earlier).
dissentowner: vote #3 on drake, #7 on timbo, #11 on regulator.
Activestick: was the #2 to vote for regulator on day 2 (later unvoted and then re-voted, so is listed lower in Mazrim's count), and also voiced suspicions of timbo very early on day 3, before anyone else had started to throw suspicions around yet. #10 on drake.
Agulati: noted suspicions of timbo early on (in day 2) and was #4 to vote for him. #12 on drake.
blaster86: not much of a voting record, but did reveal his role. Presumption of his innocence is based on mason not being MGMT. Also first player to reveal identity.
undercoverbrother: #6 on regulator, #6 on drake.
octothorp: noted suspicions on timbo on day 1, posted about timbo’s invisible mode on day 2. Revealed role. #9 on drake, #9 on regulator.

Here are guys I'm on suspicious of:

anduril: he voiced suspicions of timbo early in day 2, hasn't been very active early in the game, is starting to be more active now. #12 for regulator, #7 for timbo. Seems most player-like of these four.
stazzy33: #7 for regulator (and then made a blanket statement the next day about how anyone who voted for regulator couldn't possibly be mafia).
halifaxdrunk: I had a theory about him earlier that I've since withdrawn, it's just too tenuous, but HD hasn't given a lot to go on either way. #6 for timbo.
aeneas: He is the only remaining person who did not vote for any of the 3 MGMT to be outed. Not a lot to go on, but made a suspicious post where, as the votes were piling up for timbo, he voted for the now exonerated Sliver/Delgar. Didn't offer much of an argument for why.

03-26-2014, 12:04 PM	#981
octothorp Franchise Player Join Date: Oct 2002 Location: not lurking Exp:	Went and reread the thread, focusing on guys who are still remaining and looking not only at how they vote, but who they voice suspicions about. Someone stating suspicions about a guy who turns out to be MGMT before the votes start to pile up is a stronger tell of being a player than how they vote. I may have missed votes here and there (it's a long thread and I did this late at night), so if you see that I've made an error about you or someone else, please correct me! Here are the guys I think have shown reasonably strong player tells: Wood: vote #2 on drake, #10 on regulator, #5 on timbo dsavillian: #6 for drake, #3 on regulator (and noted suspicions of regulator earlier). dissentowner: vote #3 on drake, #7 on timbo, #11 on regulator. Activestick: was the #2 to vote for regulator on day 2 (later unvoted and then re-voted, so is listed lower in Mazrim's count), and also voiced suspicions of timbo very early on day 3, before anyone else had started to throw suspicions around yet. #10 on drake. Agulati: noted suspicions of timbo early on (in day 2) and was #4 to vote for him. #12 on drake. blaster86: not much of a voting record, but did reveal his role. Presumption of his innocence is based on mason not being MGMT. Also first player to reveal identity. undercoverbrother: #6 on regulator, #6 on drake. octothorp: noted suspicions on timbo on day 1, posted about timbo’s invisible mode on day 2. Revealed role. #9 on drake, #9 on regulator. Here are guys I'm on suspicious of: anduril: he voiced suspicions of timbo early in day 2, hasn't been very active early in the game, is starting to be more active now. #12 for regulator, #7 for timbo. Seems most player-like of these four. stazzy33: #7 for regulator (and then made a blanket statement the next day about how anyone who voted for regulator couldn't possibly be mafia). halifaxdrunk: I had a theory about him earlier that I've since withdrawn, it's just too tenuous, but HD hasn't given a lot to go on either way. #6 for timbo. aeneas: He is the only remaining person who did not vote for any of the 3 MGMT to be outed. Not a lot to go on, but made a suspicious post where, as the votes were piling up for timbo, he voted for the now exonerated Sliver/Delgar. Didn't offer much of an argument for why.