The truth is, it's difficult to buy a bad car these days...you can buy a Mitsu or a Chrysler and then shoot yourself, but, the reality is autos these days are all pretty good.
There are some that are 'better' than others but, often, you are splitting hairs and it's subjective.
I know what I like, what I don't, and what I can't live without. That drives my buying decision; I like sedans, I don't like trucks, I'm very fussy about interior appointments, fit, finish, panel fit, paint and stuff like that....that's why I buy Japanese, it suits me personally. Even if it doesn't suit the dude next door with the Ford SUV....
When people ask me for advice, I encourage them to go drive a bunch of stuff with an open mind and then start to narrow down what they like, don't and have to have...and what fits financially. I know many people who have over-bought (or leased) and then haven't been able to customize, maintain or repair the car.
My advice: drive everything in your specific category, buy what you can afford to own, and make sure you don't let the dealer sell you silly crap you don't need.
If the OP gets a Hyundai, a Toyota or a Honda, he's probably going to be happy...
But please, let us continue to debate. I love talking about cars