I do excuse the odd flaw, I said as much above. Or I tried to.
There are lots of "flaws" in FOTR and ROTK, if you even want to call them that, whose merits are open to debate. Some are baffling, some are regrettable, and some are lot of them are just a byproduct of a conversion to film medium and had to be done. Certain things are going to be left out, certain things changed.
The problem with TTT isn't flaws, it's that the movie they made only vaguely resembled TTT. The whole movie was a (blockbusteresque) flaw, with bits of good Middle Earthery interspersed into it... as opposed to the other two which were largely good Middle Earthery with bits of flaws interspersed.
|