[Maritime Q-Scout]

I've been reading this thread for a few days now.

Here's the conclusion I've come to based on what has been posted here:

Rerun requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Until that time he believes Harper is innocent until proven guilty (which is ironic for two reasons: (1) bevause of his belief of defence attorneys and their role in the criminal justice system; (2) he doesn't hold anyone other than Harper to this standard such as Duffy or Wright). The double standard is what is making every other poster pull their hair out.

Secondly, everyone else is holding Harper to a balance of probabilities standard. Since this is the standard Rerun is holding everyone BUT Harper, posters are getting frustrated.



If Rerun wants to hold Harper to a criminal standard that's perfectly fine, and his Harper defences are perfectly valid. They are. Period. There isn't any hard evidence put forward.

On a balance of probabilities it is really hard to believe that Harper wasn't involved when everyone around him was, especially given the death grip control he has on the party.

Two different standards, pick one and go with it. But if you go with beyond a reasonable doubt, given what was posted in this thread so far, Duffy is innocent.