I'm surprised at amount of people going for Nieuwendyk. For me it's Iginla by quite a wide margin. I don't think Nieuwendyk was ever a top 10 player in the league or even at any time the best player on his team. Iginla was both of those for the bulk of his career. And Iginla isn't done yet.
Interesting debate for sure, maybe I will have to rethink it.
Iginla
Macinnis
MacDonald
Niewendyk
|