He's still young - it remains to be seen whether he will rack up more cups and accomplishments, or if he is one more hit away from becoming a "what-if" like Lemieux/Lindros (not saying Lindros is in this conversation, but he is a prime example of domination until mid-late 20's).
Gretzky is undeniable in terms of peak and longevity.
Orr/Lemieux are right there in peak, but don't have longevity.
As has been said, it's hard to argue at present because things are so different. Having only 1 cup is a bit of a detractor for me, but if he can get 2 more before he is 30 then could be in the convo with Orr/Lem.
It's interesting to look at Lebron vs. Jordan. 3 years ago you would have said that Lebron was a helluva player, but not in the conversation. Now, he is 20% better than the next best player in the league, and looks to be unstoppable for the next few years. If Crosby can get it together in the playoffs, it could be the same thing.
|