View Single Post
Old 10-15-2013, 11:50 AM   #233
strombad
Lifetime Suspension
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Textcritic View Post
I completely agree that Yakupov's attitude leaves a lot to be desired, and his comments are questionable. However, what he actually said is not quite accurately presented in yours (and a number of others') comments in this thread.

Here is the quote from the Edmonton Journal:


I don't think there is much more one can say about the first response. He's understandably unhappy, and acknowledges that he must do as the coach says.


Now, I have seen a lot of people claim from his response that he has asserted that he will not alter his game and work harder on the defensive side of the puck; as moon puts it: "I won't skate, hit or play defense". Yakupov does NOT say this. In actual fact, in his second response he does seem to concede the point: he says that he won't change, but he may try to show a higher commitment to defense and the forecheck. I agree that his comments are a concern, in large part because he seems to be saying opposite things from one clause to the next. Equally concerning is that his commitment here seems extremely soft. But, I do not think that he has shown the sort of refusal to commit to team defense that some here have interpreted from his responses.


This is probably where the greatest concern lies. No one wants to hear their star player first remark that he doesn't want to play harder, and then admit that this is not part of his game. However, take care again in noting what he has and has not said here:

· Yakupov admits that defensive hockey is hard work, and he doesn't like doing it.
· He has NOT conceded that these are things that he will not try to improve upon. He has only indicated that such improvement will be unpleasant, and up to this point have not been a feature in his game.

I think his comments are a concern, and I would be extremely disappointed were they made by a Flames player. However, some of them are getting blown a little bit out of proportion.
While I agree that his comments are being slightly over-exaggerated, you totally focused on the wrong quote in terms of your argument.
The part people are concerned about is the SAME part you are concerned about. You focused on the second quote, nobody cares about that in terms of making their assumptions on his level of defensive commitment, but the last quote where he basically says skating hard and back checking isn't part of his game and he doesn't want to do it? THAT is the issue.
That's where moon is gathering his assumption that Yaks won't skate hard or play defence from, because Yaks SAYS skating hard and playing defence isn't part of his game and he doesn't think he should have to do it.
We can all read, and we're all reading and being concerned about the exact same quote you are, so I'm not sure what point you were trying to make.
strombad is offline  
The Following User Says Thank You to strombad For This Useful Post: