Quote:
Originally Posted by rubecube
I make the same argument about Eli Manning. Those Giants Super Bowl teams were good, and Manning made a couple of clutch throws, but I don't count the Tyree catch as one of them. Take away Kyle Williams gaffes in the NFC Championship game two years ago, the coin-flip Tyree catch, and Manning's resume is incredibly pedestrian.
EDIT: His 2011 season was pretty remarkable.
|
people love to cut down RIvers and his past couple years but does anyone seriously think that if Eli was a Charger, that he would have any rings? he relied on his defense and running game. In the second super bowl, he was in control and played well but he was playing the NE defense, not the Giant defense that Brady had to face.... sometime with QB's such as Flacco and Eli, they are put in a pretty good situations, not saying they arent good because they are but the whole " how many rings?" argument is weak.