Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post - What teams had the all-time best collection of goons?

Scorponok · 08-26-2013, 11:51 AM

Waiting for the new season got me to thinking, what team had the best collection of goons/fighters? Calgary has had quite a few good ones, and if I had to ice a line of goons, I'd go with:

Eric Godard
Sandy McCarthy
Tim Hunter
Brian McGratton
Stu Grimsom

Edmonton's best goons were probably
Marty McSorley
Dave Hunter
Dave Semenko
George Laraque
Dave Manson

Vancouver had
Gino Odjick
Garth Butcher
Tiger Williams
Donald Brashear
Matt Cooke

Out of the 3 Western Canadian teams, I think Calgary had the best collection of goons. But who had the all-time best collection?

08-26-2013, 11:51 AM	#1
Scorponok Crash and Bang Winger Join Date: Apr 2006 Exp:	What teams had the all-time best collection of goons? Waiting for the new season got me to thinking, what team had the best collection of goons/fighters? Calgary has had quite a few good ones, and if I had to ice a line of goons, I'd go with: Eric Godard Sandy McCarthy Tim Hunter Brian McGratton Stu Grimsom Edmonton's best goons were probably Marty McSorley Dave Hunter Dave Semenko George Laraque Dave Manson Vancouver had Gino Odjick Garth Butcher Tiger Williams Donald Brashear Matt Cooke Out of the 3 Western Canadian teams, I think Calgary had the best collection of goons. But who had the all-time best collection?