Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post - All Time Teams

powderjunkie · 08-07-2013, 03:01 PM

Also, my team Western Canada:

Kariya - Messier - Howe
Trottier - Sakic - Neely
Wendel Clark - Yzerman - Recchi
Bucyk - Clarke - Tiger Williams
Toews - Anderson - Iginla

Niedermayer - Shore
Keith - Patrick
Wesley - Weber

Sawchuk
Glen Hall/Bower/Fuhr/Vernon/Belfour/Osgood

If it were a threeway battle with Ontario and Quebec, I rank:

Forwards
Western Canada has the most complete centres with decent wingers + most toughness, Ontario has great playmakers with good wingers + most overall skill, and Quebec is solid all around. Bit of a toss up depending on style of play.

Defence
1. Ontario
2. WC/Quebec (Bourque edges Niedermayer, but the other 5 are pretty similar IMO)

Goaltending
1. Quebec
2. WC (I take Sawchuk over Dryden, but that is the subjectivist or comparisons)
3. Ontario

I think any series between these teams would probably go to 7...not sure who I'd pick!

08-07-2013, 03:01 PM	#4
powderjunkie Franchise Player Join Date: Dec 2011 Exp:	Also, my team Western Canada: Kariya - Messier - Howe Trottier - Sakic - Neely Wendel Clark - Yzerman - Recchi Bucyk - Clarke - Tiger Williams Toews - Anderson - Iginla Niedermayer - Shore Keith - Patrick Wesley - Weber Sawchuk Glen Hall/Bower/Fuhr/Vernon/Belfour/Osgood If it were a threeway battle with Ontario and Quebec, I rank: Forwards Western Canada has the most complete centres with decent wingers + most toughness, Ontario has great playmakers with good wingers + most overall skill, and Quebec is solid all around. Bit of a toss up depending on style of play. Defence 1. Ontario 2. WC/Quebec (Bourque edges Niedermayer, but the other 5 are pretty similar IMO) Goaltending 1. Quebec 2. WC (I take Sawchuk over Dryden, but that is the subjectivist or comparisons) 3. Ontario I think any series between these teams would probably go to 7...not sure who I'd pick! Last edited by powderjunkie; 08-07-2013 at 03:03 PM.