Quote:
Originally Posted by _Q_
HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.
Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.
|
The only D I'd take over him is Brodie, and that's only because I think Brodie is going to be a star in 18 months.
Giordano has one season that's anywhere close to Phaneuf's middle of the road. Not one D on our roster can impact the game physically, to say nothing of their ability to do it at phaneuf's level.
Everyone thought he was the next great generational talent at the position. He's not. He is a number one D on a playoff team. Which means he doesn't suck nearly as much as you think he does. And he certainly isn't an ahl d. And when you say you'd take four current flames over him, you're lying.