Lots of good points in this thread.
I don't think these tests will affect draft position much but what they illustrate is where some of them are development-wise and what they can improve upon. Also, it can be one small indication of their work ethic.
As Azure mentioned, they can be very useful if you're wondering if a particular kid might be able to play in the NHL next year. However, I don't agree with comparing to the NFL - very different game where teams draft athletes and then teach them to play. If a guy is 6'9" and runs a 4.4 40, you can teach him how to be a defensive lineman. Simply can't happen in hockey.
Another useful application is following how your prospect is improving over time. I am not going to decide between Lindholm and Monahan based on combine tests. However, once I choose my guy (Monahan), I am going to use his combine tests to a) develop a summer regiment for him, and b) to see how he has improved over the summer, come September (and again next September)
|