Quote:
Originally Posted by gottabekd
Yea, that's what I'm saying. Someone before was saying that maybe that scene didn't convey the message the writers intended. I'm saying that it was purposely a little ambiguous. It puts you in Carl and Herhsel's shoes, and you have to decide for yourself if Carl did the right thing.
|
Dude was part of a group that was attacking your camp. Sure, he seemed to be retreating and stumbled on your group, but what do you do with the guy if you don't shoot him? Take him prisoner? Let him join your group? Way easier dead.