Quote:
Originally Posted by Enoch Root
What I am saying is that Subban has faced the same players as the other goalies in the OHL, so how has he done vs them? Likewise for Gillies vs other NCAA goalies.
Subban has pretty much identical numbers to Binnington and they are leading most catagories.
As good as Gillies has been, there are goalies in the NCAA with stupid-good numbers. Gillies is 16th in GAA, 9th in SVP and 2nd in SOs
|
If you want to measure Gillies against the whole of NCAA (and not just Hockey East) then I think you'd have to measure Subban against the whole of the CHL and not just the OHL. He still comes out impressive but he's 6th (or 7th depending on how liberal you set the min. GP requirement) in sv% by that standard.
They're both having really really good years. Statistically they're so close that if you want to grade one over the other I think you have to make an environment judgement NCAA Division I - Hockey East vs. CHL - OHL. That's absent any scouting assessments. I can't tell you whose better by having seen them because I've seen them both play to few games