IMO Macdonald hasn't played well enough to be considered to be anything more than a capable back up goalie. Even if we snuck into the playoffs, would a first round ousting after 4,5 or 6 games really change anything?
If we want a run of any significance then yes, we need Kipper. (Unless your considering tanking the season) He can single handily win us games, which is something you need from a starter. I don't think Macdonald can do that against the upper echelon teams.
|