Quote:
Originally Posted by Parallex
I mean take this hypothetical... you expect a guy to score 50 goals a year and be a really good tough minute two-way forward... say that guy scores 40 goals and everything else was as expected? I mean does that guy actually get graded as less then a "C"?
|
I might not expect a guy to definitely hit 50 goals, though your logic is fairly sound as the goal scoring is toggled. If Iginla scored 25 and got 50 over 82 games, I'd give him a lower score than Jackman scoring double digits goals if they played the rest of the game as they did now.
Agreed that it's slightly flawed, but I prefer having a system that measures grinders up to stars on the same level. No "Stars get passes for scoring lots, but less than expected" getting higher rankings than bottom 6 guys playing their hearts out.