Quote:
Originally Posted by moon
Brodie- A
Bouwmeester- B+
Wideman- C
Smith- C
Sarich- C
Giordano- D
Butler- D
Gio probably has played overall better than Smith and Sarich but he has been so bad and disappointing at times that it is frustrating to watch.
Bouwmeester has had moments where he has looked great but also had more defensive breakdowns and complete misses this year so that holds him back from being an A.
Brodie has been great and outside of a few errors expected from a young guy he is progressing really well. Looks solid in the top 4 even playing with a guy like Wideman which can't be easy.
|
Oh Moon you lovable scamp! I agree with most of your grades but not all.
Wideman- A
Bouwmeester- A
Brodie- B+ ( I think hes been good, but i was expecting a bit more offense, but that seems to be coming)
Gio - D
Smith- C
Butler- D
Sarich- C
I would seriously look at moving Gio a team like Detroit would overpay at this point I think. I dont think hes been good the last couple of seasons. Though maybe he's whats made Bouwmeester look good. If we get end up looking like we wont make the playoffs I would be dealing gio for sure.