I'm sure my opinion will be unpopular, but I kind of agree with the state on this one. On a spectrum ranging from artificial insemination by an anonymous donor at a clinic to "donating" by personally planting the seed, this falls right inbetween.
IMO, you you can't absolve a person from paternity obligations if you wrote a letter saying that he "donated" sperm via intercourse. You can absolve a person from paternity by using an independent third party clinic. These people chose to do something inbetween, and the line has to be drawn somewhere right around where this case lies. I think this guy should lose this case to set a precedent for similar cases.
I think you're crazy to just drop off a jar of jizz to a couple of people (lesbian or not) who want to have a baby.
|