Think it was 8/10, but if it had come out before FOTR I would probably think higher of it because there were some similarities, it really set up the 2nd/3rd movies, and after seeing the first I don't think extending it to 3 is going to be an issue at all
I thought Freeman was great as Bilbo, the HFR was a little jarring at first but after the first 15 or so minutes I got used to it and really enjoyed it
The Bilbo/Gollum stuff was fantastic
|