I don't want to turn this into a match between Inner-City versus out of city, but I just found it intresting that all your points could be used for the Mission area where I live.
-Commute time is 5 mins (although you do win on the noise department)
- Pathways along the river, numerous parks, coulee like areas.
-Lot's of wildlife, Deer, Rabbits, Coyotes etc.
- Tons of people walking around, never feel unsafe day or night
- Live on the river, dog loves to go swimming in it.
-Shopping is all within walking distance. Safeway down the block, Chinook mall 2 mins away.
- Outdoor pool in Stanley Park, more river, parks and paths
-Nearby the saddledome, Corral, bowling, movie theatres etc.
Anyway, not going to turn this into an argument, just want to point out that many of the things people use to justify moving out of the city, can be found right here. After living in Bridlewood, you could never pull me out of Mission.
. However, I do understand the appeal. If you don't work in Calgary, I would say find the neighbourhood best suited for you.