Quote:
Originally Posted by moon
I think that it has to be done in groupings, similar to what you have but without numbers.
Lulay right now is in a class of his own.
Not sure how Durant is seen as better than Ray, Burris or AC. I would say they are all in the same category having shown the ability to win games on their own and be great but in the case of the latter 3 the diminished skills with age and no longer able to win games on their own as often and in the case of Durant not having the skill or ability to win games often enough.
Tate, Jyles and Brink/Pierce would be in the bottom 3rd due to inexperience/lack of proof they are any good (Brink/Tate), injury (Pierce) and long history of below average to sucking (Jyles).
I think the clear thing in ranking guys is that there is a big drop off after Lulay and that QB'ing in the CFL is very weak right now. I can't say that it would be that shocking to see any of the teams outside of BC with a new starting QB for the final 5-8 games of the year, and not due to injury. I doubt that it happens in TO, Hamilton or Calgary based on the commitment they made to the new guy or Sask based on the deification of Durant there but based on their play it could easily be warranted in all the cities.
|
Durant had a great 1st game and may be having a bounce back year. If he has time to let him get the ball into peoples hands he can be very dangerous. Take away his time tho and he becomes Burris-like. For now tho based on week 1 and previous play, I can't put Ray or Calvillo ahead of him. Both Qb's are aging and slowing down a lot.