Quote:
|
Originally Posted by octothorp
Further to that point, one must remember that music snobs (and I use that term endearingly) are a big part of the retro-music industry, even more-so than in the modern industry. For a band to be considered great decades after they've stopped recording, they have to be critically endorsed, not just popular. They have to be referenced and adored not only by later critics, but also by later musicians. As others have done, I have to dispute the notion that Nickleback will achieve that sort of influence. I'd liken them to NKOTB. Popular during their own time among the mainstream, but without any critical endorsement, and actually despised by critics for what they symbolize. Hence they'll have little staying power. On the other hand, few critically adored but unpopular bands have long-term appeal, either. You need a delicate balance of the two. Perhaps Nickleback will, at some point, achieve the sort of critical success that would allow them to endure. I've heard nothing in their music, and seen nothing in reactions to their music that would lead me to believe this will happen.
|
Because numerous awards aren't enough? I don't recall the New Kids ever winning any...
Let's take a quick peek down memory lane here... Based on the theory that AC/DC will be forever loved, and Nickelback will be forgotten quickly:
AC/DC:
nominated for: 4 grammys, 1 MTV Video Music award
in 30 years
Nickelback:
nominated for: 2 American Music Awards, 4 Grammys, and Kroeger for his duet with Josey Scott for an additional 3
has already won: 5 Juno Awards, 2 MuchMusic Video Awards, and 1 MTV Video Music Award.
has worked with artists such as Josey Scott, Kid Rock, and Santana.
In six years.
No critical success? Surely you jest.