Quote:
Originally Posted by transplant99
No he isnt the same guy he was coming out of USC, but that doent mean he isnt still very capable, and right now miles ahead of either Garrard or jason Campbell for that matter.
|
I'll take Campbell ahead of Palmer. Campbell doesn't get enough credit for being a good game manager. He's not going to put up Brees or Rogers numbers but he's great in play action which helps the running game and makes key throws when needed. He's got an 11-7 record with a team that averaged 4 wins a seaon for 8 years. He's not the scrub you make him out to be as this is the first season in his career that he had he was working in the same offense as the year before and was well on his way to leading the Raiders to a 9 or 10 win season before the injury. Like Sylvanfan said Palmer today is closer to Elvis Grbac, or Trent Dilfer than he is the guy that started his career with the Bengals. I'll take Campbell over that.