[OILFAN #81]

Originally Posted by Clever_Iggy

And everyone and their dog knew Jerry Rice was going to run a slant. He holds almost every major receiving record you can own (receptions, yards, TDs), played for 20 season, won 4 Superbowls, etc.

Jim Brown ranks 9th in rushing yards, 5th in rushing TDs, and 2nd in rushing attempts. He does rank 1st in yards per game. Brown only won 1 NFL Championship and only played 9 seasons.

IMO, it's not even close and I'm not sure why Brown is ranked as the highest RB (Smith, Tomlinson for sure and even Peyton or Sanders are in the conversation) let alone that high at all.

Edit: It should be noted my comment isn't that Rice is the greatest all time, it's simply that he's significantly better than Jim Brown. IMO, Jim Brown doesn't make the top 10.

I don't get that part. You say Tomlinson and Smith for sure and yet Walter Payton only as a maybe? Walter Payton was better then both the first two you mentioned.