Well I'll chime in... I loved it. I seen both the Prestige and Memento at home and after both of those I watched them again immediately after, wish I could have done that with Inception. It was eye candy but a very smart movie as well. Christopher Nolan is one of the best out there now, no doubt about it.
I quickly looked through the thread but I thought Tom Hardy (Earnes) was a scene stealer. The guy is criminally underrated as an actor currently. A lot of people talk about Christian Bale's change from the Machinest to bulking up for Batman... but Hardy went from this skinny twirp in Star Trek..
To this in Bronson
He's set to play Max in the new Mad Max movie so it will be interesting to see what press he starts to get when that comes out.
DiCaprio was great again, even thought the usually annoying Ellen Page was good too. Not much else I can say that others haven't... but what a movie.
The ending... loved it. I smiled and groaned at the same time, seemed like everyone in the theater had the same reaction, loved it.