Well the bass pro shops (tm) one has a two star review. Looks really flaky. Polaris is a good brand for a tent I think. I've had my 4-man Eureka for about 15 years and still seems 'modern' haha. Nothing wrong with it at all and very sturdy. Have you checked out Wholesale Sports? They don't have big Eureka's right now, but a good selection anyways:
http://ca.wholesalesports.com/storef...rod251435.html