View Single Post
Old 11-01-2009, 09:16 PM   #32
flip
Lifetime Suspension
 
flip's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Sec 216
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mean Mr. Mustard View Post
I think that this is likely one of the major reasons for the Dieppe raid (and it was a raid - not an invasion). The Soviets made some massive sacrifices in World War II that should not be ignored and I can completely understand their urging the other allies for more action, it is just unfortunate that action involved the disastrous raid. The raid was tragically flawed from it's beginnings, whether it be the choice in location or the tanks inability to move on the beaches due to the loose rocks breaking the tracks, the poor fire support or the underestimating of the German forces. In general I can't help but think that the entire thing was doomed from the start and Canadian forces paid a massive price.

Umm thanks?


Yeah, I didn't ask for a history lesson but OK, I'm sure some of the other posters aren't familiar with WWII history. I guess you couldn't resist showing your knowledge on the subject even if it had nothing to do with my post or the question I asked.

I asked someone whose family was involved in Dieppe if they have any feelings on the fact that thousands of Canadian troops were basically sacrificed for purely political reasons with almost no strategic or tactical advantages.

Just curious if there is any bitterness there because of the surrounding factors involved at Dieppe.
flip is offline   Reply With Quote