Quote:
Originally Posted by moon
I say he is overrated because too often I see people say Brady, Manning and McNabb. Perhaps it is because they feel the need to throw another name in with those 2 who are clearly better than anyone else in the league but to me he is way too often included with those guys.
|
Yeah, I wouldn't put him up with those two, but you could make an argument to slot him at the top of the next tier of guys (i.e. Rivers, Brees, Roethlisberger).
As far as the big games go, I've seen McNabb win some pretty important games all by himself. I know they lost in last year's NFC Championship, but McNabb basically put the team on his back and carried them to as close as they were, only to be let down by the defense.