Two wildcard is fine with me, BUT I did have another idea for a category if you're open to hearing it?? What about a "guilty pleasures" category, defined as the guy you think is hot but you know it's a pretty unconventional choice. As an example, I'd use Puxlut's posting of Jay from Jay & Silent Bob. Or another example is I have a friend who has a huge thing for Nicolas Cage.
But if it's too late to add categories, we can just go with the 2 wildcards for sure!!