[cyclone3483]

Troutie, you know where I stand on spiritual issues and I know where you stand.

That being said, I don't view this as a spiritual issue at all, but rather an issue of legal right to restrict membership. I am surprised Scouts are strict on spirituality. I always thought they were for everyone.

It is the right of any organization to determine who will be members. The Jewish temple exclude non-Jews from becoming Rabbis. The NAACP restrict membership based on race. Even the YMCA/YWCA could potentially restrict access to Christians alone (they don't, but they could if they wanted to). If it is in their government approved mandate (for non-profits and charities), then they can restrict membership.

Or if they are an unofficial organization (KKK and Nazi Party come to mind), I'm sure they have restrictive rules on membership.

You must know some of the legally stuff around that.

In this case, it is unfortunate that Scouts and Beavers are strict on this rule as it is a great place for boys to enjoy new experiences. I am surprised by it. I don't know if there is an equivalent alternative without the restrictions. It isn't palatable for those on the outside wanting in, but it is what it is.

I guess the argument could be made that you could start up your own organization if you are excluded from theirs. Much like starting up a German language school in Calgary if you have German heritage, want your kids to be bilingual in English/German, and there are no German language schools. Not easy, time consuming, money draining, etc.

I hope you find a solution. I'm sorry your boys don't have that opportunity. I feel for you, buddy.