Here are my picks for best picks that aren't my picks.
Action/Adventure EG-Bones
Sitcom-in a close contest, Jagger-How I Met Your Mother
Comedy Open-Bobblehead-Carol Burnett Show
Pre '80-Windom SNL
Drama (heavy acting) - Windom - Twin Peaks
Canadian - Jerzee Girl -Kids in the Hall
Crime/Law- Barnes - Dexter
Cartoon- in a squeaker Bobblehead - Family Guy
Fantasy/Sci-Fi -Halifax Drunk - Firefly
Medical - Halifax Drunk- M*A*S*H*
Talk Show- Matty C - Late Night With Conan
Mini-Series/TV Movie- Miss Teeks- Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee
Reality Elimination- Matty C - Fear Factor
Reality Ongoing - DION - Deadliest Catch!
Game Show- Dion - Win Ben Stein's Money
Soap- prottttttotype - Days of Our Lives
Educational/Informative - getbak -Sesame Street
World - tie (sue me) Sadora's Spaced and Windom's The Young Ones
Wildcard #1- superflyer - Miami Vice
Wildcard #2 - FlamesguySJ- Criminal Minds
Displaced's TV draft winner is......Windom URL by 1/2 a vote!