well, using players that only donned the flaming C, with such a small sample size, and given how awful it was at times, its hard not to select third overall,
Goalie, Mike Vernon
Though his second go round was pretty pitiful, when he started his career he was great. Leading the Flames to a Stanley Cup final berth in 1986 as a rookie, he would continue to play in Calgary until 1994, before eventually being traded back to Calgary in 2000
Eventually most of his stats as a flame will be surpassed, but he lived the dream and won a cup with his home town team in '89. He is currently one of two players to have his number retired by the club