Quote:
Originally posted by TheCommodoreAfro+May 24 2005, 09:09 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (TheCommodoreAfro @ May 24 2005, 09:09 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> <!--QuoteBegin-Mean Mr. Mustard@May 25 2005, 12:44 AM
I think you have it mixed up, the Japanese individual in the example would't understand the insult, while the outsider (I assume that Rubber Ducky isn't Japanese) would have found it offensive. I think that this from the horses mouth isn't exactly what you are trying to get across.
But can someone explain what I asked before, how is it racist instead of derogitory towards a nation. Unless the Japanese are a race, but I have never heard that to be the case.
|
Am I completely ignored here? By the likes of MMM even? JHChrist....Can anyone at least reference my posts and point out what Rouge and others are saying. Japs is ignorant. It's a race label tag like chinks, ####s or any other. Let's not get into it - acceptance and moving on is what's needed here not rampant justification. If you need help, let my wife or any of her friends (still quite a few in Calgary) come over and bash you over the head if you are looking for boundaries to pursue in your desire to redefine what racist comments are all about . There is no argument so give it up. [/b][/quote]
I understand that it is an iggnorant thing to say to the fullest degree, but at the same time is being ignorant towards the populace of a nation, really equitable to being racist towards the populace of a nation. I am not saying that what he said was right, justified, or not extremely rude, but I don't know whether that necessarly adds up to being racist in itself. The Japanese people (who the insult is refering to) are not a race, well at least no more than the population of Canada is a race, or the population of America is a race, or the population of Brazil is a race. I don't know whether my definition of race is skewed, but I never really saw it where the population of a nation is considered a race, merely because they are the population of a nation. I know you might say I am being woefully ignorant towards their plight, and towards the term, but I don't know whether it would be considered ignorant, any more than a term such as Polak or Canuck (obviously to refer to individuals from Poland and Ukraine respectively).
That being said, he obviously shouldn't have used the term, but I really have to question if it is racist, or just ignorant?