Oh, well, I think I am AK'ing Jerzee (sorry) and I will make my pick myself.
Team Idiot Box would like to select in the category of Fantasy/Sci Fi, Supernatural. It's not officially listed in the fantasy category, but I think it fits there, given the demon chasing and such, that seems rather fantastic to me, but if people take issue, I will move it around.
The premise: two hot brothers chase down demons and assorted other bad stuff.
Supernatural trailer Season One:
Supernatural Fan made trailer:
Superhot Jensen Ackles lipsyncs Eye of the Tiger